|
|
|
Franklin MWD-1450 Merriam-Webster Dictionary & Thesaurus |  |
|
| Product Reviews from Amazon.com (Rating System 1 to 5) |
| Review | Rating | Last Updated | Nice for the price
I read some of the other reviews and one must consider the price of an item. This item may not be th greatest, but it is inexpensive. In my experience with this item, it is a worthwhile small investment. I have had mine for a couple years and use it regularly. I am considering getting a model that has more info and options on it. Overall this is a good model. Take care. | 4 | Today | Not as good as the MWD-1470.
This product is not as good as the MWD-1470 (which i also reviewed) for one reason:
The touch screen.
You touch it, get fingerprints all over it, try to clean it, push all the touch buttons, mess it up.
Get the MWD-1470.
Last Word:
This is a "B."
| 3 | Today | Okay.
The display is kinda lousy. But it really comes in handy at times but if you have trouble reading the display, then save your money and purchase a Palm PDA or Sony PDA with maybe a backlight function. I use both this device and my Palm Zire 21 for reading and reference. So, I prefer to use the Palm Zire 21 with the eReader Pro application installed with a reference title but the dictionaries on eReader.com aren't as easy to read because the font is too small. So, get this device if you just need an electronic book reader and portable reference device. | 3 | Today | very disappointing
there are many bad points about this electronic dictionary.
a) the thesaurus is terrible. when you search a word, it only gives you about 4 or 5 synonyms.
b) the dictionary is also very poor. the definitions are not very easy to understand, sometimes it gives a rather stupid answer. for example, lets say you didn't know what the word 'indignation' meant. you type in the word, and the definition will say something like 'to be indignant'. hiw are you meant to learn anyting from that??
at one point i got so fed up with this piece of junk i resorted to the trusty book-form dictionary. buy a book version instead; this thing isn't worth half it's price. | 2 | Today | Not Quite What I Was Looking For, But Still Functional
Let me start off by saying that I have owned both the Franklin SCD-1870 and the MWD-1450. After using the 1450 for about a week, I returned it to the store where I purchased it. I will present this review as a comparison between the Franklin SCD-1870 and the MWD-1450. Content: The winner is the 1870. You know that the 1870 has a larger database by the specifications, but it really becomes apparent when you use the device. With the 1450, many words are available for lookup, but it only tells you the part of speech. To find the definition, you have to access the thesaurus for a brief definition with synonyms. So far, the 1870 has contained every definition that I have asked from it, with the exception of some modified words. For example, if you search for `ardently,' it will only return that it is an adverb. If you want the definition, you have to enter the root, or `ardent.' Others have mentioned the 1450's lack of phonetic spellings, which I did find to be a disappointment. The 1870 also lacks the printed phonetics, but makes up for it with the speaking ability. On the topic of speaking, the 1870 does pretty well. It is a little quite, but I think that is a good thing. I don't have to worry about accidentally speaking a word too loudly in the office. The synthesized voice is a little hard to follow while reading the definitions due to an unnatural flow. Some words are spoken with no space between them, while others leave a ½ second between words. The 1870 has a lot more to offer past the dictionary and thesaurus capabilities, most of which I don't have much use for. It has a menu for "Signs, Symbols and Tables" that lists lots of... well, signs, symbols and tables. The content varies from the astronomical symbols used to label the planets on a sky chart, to the start-dates of the Jewish calendar, to the books of the Bible, to the elements of the Periodic Table. Could be useful to some, but I don't find myself needing to access that information very much. Both have some word games, with the 1870 having at least twice as many as the 1450. They both use cheesy graphics for transitions (winning or losing a game) that you can easily turn off. Due to the poor screen of the 1450 (see below) I did not spend much time on the games. The 1870's games are entertaining. One feature that I miss from the 1450 is a "Word Learning" option. It was sort-of like a "word of the day," except it would give you a new word every time you powered up (I guess you could call it "word of the session"). I will not comment on the organizer capabilities of each device because it is something that I personally have no use for. I can imagine, however, that this feature would have been helpful while I was a high school student (10 years ago!). Screen: With the number of electronic devices incorporating LCD's today, the quality to cost ratio is usually extremely high. Not so, however, with the 1450. The screen is MISERABLE. Aside from the inconvenient screen size, the quality simply sucks. You have to have absolutely perfect lighting to read the screen with ease; lighting that I do not have in my office or next to my bed at home. It was my sole reason for returning the 1450. The 1870 on the other hand, has a screen that is clear, legible, and a pleasure to read, and is much larger and more efficient at providing information -that's what I expect. Ergonomics: I initially preferred the horizontal layout of the 1450, but have grown to favor the vertical design of the 1870. The vertical arrangement makes it natural to hold in one had while navigating the system. The 1450's keyboard is easier to use since the buttons are larger and spaced further apart. However, the buttons seem like the printing will wear off very quickly. On the 1870, the buttons manageable. Construction: Here, I would have to favor the 1450 for its cover. It is hard and opens and snaps shut with ease. I would have no worries dropping it into my pocket and forgetting that it was there. The 1870 has a semi-soft cover that just flips around from the front to the back. It is convenient, but it doesn't protect the screen and buttons as well and the attachment feature seems rather flimsy. The 1450 tries to be high-tech with `touch-screen technology.' It is a waste. You can clearly see the wiring lines on the screen that make it function, and you end up with lots of fingerprints and smudges at the bottom of the already crowded screen. The 1870 uses much more robust dedicated buttons below the screen to access the menu items. For use on a desk, I prefer the 1870. The 1450 was nice... until you start typing. While pressing the letters to the outside, the unit rocks side-to-side, which gets annoying. The 1870 can lay nice and flat, and can easily be propped up for easy viewing as seen in all of the advertising photos. In this position, it is not practical to enter or scroll through information. Recommendation: Both units provide sufficient value to the user. The MWD-1450 would be more suited for a younger user, perhaps elementary students up to high school. The hard cover makes it that much more rugged and able to withstand the abuse of a backpack. Also, children are less demanding on quality and ease of use and are less likely to complain about the poor screen. From high school on up, the SCD-1870 is the definite winner. It has a far greater ease of use, many more functions, and a larger content that is demanded at a higher level. Overall, the 1450 is OK and the 1870 is GREAT. Enjoy! | 3 | Today | Writing Companion
I have purchased two separate Franklin Bookman Dictionary Thesaurus & Game electronics over the last 7 years and have been most pleased. The amount of writing I do enables me to be sufficiently supported by means of this electronic device. I have found it to be more current in dictionary/thesaurus word capabilities than Microsoft software offers and quite honestly, it goes everywhere I do... What I am currently seeking to find out though, is whether or not there is a yearly or bi-yearly software update with respect to the 2002 version. If this can be answered please acknowledge... | 4 | Today | great tool!
I bought the MWD-1450 after accidentally breaking the screen on my Franlkin Pagemark dictionary which I had for only 2 months. This one has basically the same set-up as the previous. The Upside: It is lightweight and portable, and you can add words to a personalized word list. Downside: no pronunication (pro-nun-si-ay-sh'n) key, screen doesn't have a led light, and word list can only hold 40 words. Overall, this is a good buy. | 3 | Today | It is a great dictionary
Well, when I was looking for an electronic dictionary, I searched the web for all of them but found this one and decided to buy it. I had my doubts but soon they were gone. This thing is really great. It has all kinds of words that I need in English and History classrooms. It is worth every penny of the 50 dollars. However, I bought mine at Circuit City. If you have any doubts about buying this little dictionary, dont because it is GREAT! | 5 | Today | Almost a Cure for Writer's Block!
My daughter's English teacher (who is very demanding but an awesome educator!) recommended this for his Honor's English class and it has been a wonderful writing tool! It has not only helped with her composition skills, but the increase in verbal vocabulary skills is noticeable, also. That's important in a world of "whatever" and less-than-literate text messaging popularity. A valuable instrument that would make an excellent gift for your favorite student or your favorite writer. | 5 | Today | wonderfully and marvolously made
BEST THING I COULD,VE EVER INVESTED IN. I CAN CARRY IT ANYWHERE I GO. YOU,LL NEVER KNOW WHEN YOU,LL NEED IT. | 5 | Today |
 We thought you might be interested in other BEST DEALS that we found for you: |
| *Pricing and product information listed is obtained from the merchants and is subject to change without notice. Shipping costs are estimated based on UPS ground within US, unless specified otherwise. While we try to validate this information,we cannot assure its validity and therefore disclaim any responsibility for its accuracy or completeness. Always check the latest price, availability, shipping, tax, and product information directly on the merchant web site before purchasing. |
|
|
|
|
Shopping Directory:
| | 
|
All Rights Reserved - AimLower.com - 2008-07-26Read our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy
Powered by 
|
|
